I am a big YWAMer and a big Keith Green fan, so my favorite hymn is definately "Holy, Holy, Holy." Keith sang that one, and his rendition (on record) ushered in the "Anastasis" mercy ship after he died in the plane crash. So that one has a lot of meaning for me. (Keith Green was a forerunner to every Contemperary Christian artist today, and few have since lived up to the standard he set) It is considered a hymn, but that may be a incorrect usage of terms because that song is more "vertical" meaning Hymns usually sing
about God, not
to God.Modern hymnals tend to have a mix of hymns and psalms, but most people call it a hymn based on the slow tempo and lack of emotion rather than on what the song is about.
I also like "A Mighty Fortress is our God" more as a matter of novelty... I mean, it sounds so solemn (sp?). It's fun to try to sing in a bass voice.
Even though this hymn is disputed because of its connection to war and its connection to American patriotism, I also like "Battlehymn of the Republic" It's just so fun to sing.
I gotta say something about the English and German hymns... A lot of the melodies, with the obvious exception of those that started as symphonies, actually started as drinking songs. I think that's a good thing to consider for people so opposed to rock and "copying" the styles of modern music.
I prefer the more "vertical" psalms, I guess, though the Bible talks about psalms (planned "vertical" songs), Hymns ("horizontal" songs), and spiritual songs (spontaneous songs) so it is good to take part in all of them. I haven't really heard that many "new" hymns, however, while I have heard a lot of rather shallow new psalms ( IMNSHO they really should be rather personal, not just all praise to God, but I'm fine with the ones that are just praise... I just wish they'd do the other kind more often...)