Haven't ranted in while (at least I don't think I have) been saving up for just such an occasion. So let me just
like so and:
[spoiler]So apparently Lauren Faust has revealed that she never intended for Scootaloo to fly. That's right, Scootaloo was planned to be disabled, wishing to be like Rainbow Dash, but never being able to achieve that, being teased in school about her disability and having to learn that what you wish for isn't the same as what you can do and accepting that her true calling is her scooter.
And yes I have a MAJOR problem with this! And yes I'm biased towards Scootaloo! And no it's not a matter of thinking this couldn't work or they can't pull it off, because if anyone can, it's them.
Now it should be said that this was Lauren's idea when she created the show and not necessarily what will appear in the show and become canon, but it does mean that there is good chance it might.
Now I have nothing against a well executed tragedy, in fact on occasion I love watching or reading them. For example the 'My little Dashie' fanfic has all the makings of a good tragedy but imo lacks a lot of emotional buildup for the reader. What I do
not like is sad stories purely for sadness sake, that has no substance or reason. A fanfic like the very popular 'Bubbles' for example imo just has no goal except to make you sad, which is stupid.
And at this point, using this arc for Scootaloo is sadness for sadness sake. First of all I never expected Scootaloo to learn to fly within the series, she is always
learning to fly, just like Sweetie Belle is always waiting for her magic to kick in. (unless she's disabled too
) Keeping the CMC grounded just makes their adventures easier to handle and script, this I understand, but we don't need Scootaloo disabled to achieve this goal.
Secondly we've already had both Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash teased in school and now they want to do the same with Scootaloo! And Twilight and Apple Bloom was teased in school. We don't need any more stories or fuel for being teased, there's enough instances already that haven't been explored yet.
So there's no reason to do this to Scootaloo except for the sake of a sad story. Especially when Scootaloo could be a great source for the 'it takes a little more effort to reach your dreams' character or 'late bloomer' character. Especially since Sweetie Belle already is the 'what I wish for and what I'm good at is different' character. Wanting to do anything to be like Rarity but obviously have a completely different talent.
Tl;dr
Scootaloo being disabled.
I'm biased!
Do not need!
Do not want!
Is not necessary![/spoiler]
What a long rant, but it feels better getting that out of my system.