Page 1 of 1

Sub and Dub Differences

PostPosted: Wed Jul 30, 2003 3:03 pm
by Master Kenzo
NOTE: If I were to censor this for spoilers, there would only be this sentence in the post. If you havn't watched Trigun and plan to, or don't care if it's spoiled or not, do not read this post.





I noticed when watching certain animes, (such a Trigun) the script differs greatly between the original Japanese, subtitles, and English dubs.

For example, during Paradise, (Trigun 23) when Wolfwood says his final line, notice the difference:

Subbed: "I guess it would be presumptous to ask for forgiveness."
Dubbed: "I guess it wouldn't be too late to ask for forgiveness." (similar to that)

Such a minor error, but it really makes or breaks the scene. Post all the differences from any anime you can find in this thread...bolding the one you like best (subbed, dubbed, or jap) Example:

Anime Name:
Episode:
---
Subbed:
Dubbed:

Simple enough...give it a shot! (This might be 300 pages long O_O)

PostPosted: Wed Jul 30, 2003 7:16 pm
by MillyFan
I haven't seen the sub of Trigun (I really want to someday) but the dub of episode 23 was a mess from what I hear.

[spoiler=Wolfwood/Milly spoiler]In the dub, in that same final scene an "and. . ." implying that Milly was indeed carrying his child, was removed from when Wolfwood was thinking about who he wanted to be with in paradise. [/spoiler]

Not *really* important. . .but the ep 23 dub wasn't the best IMHO.

PostPosted: Wed Jul 30, 2003 10:01 pm
by TheMelodyMaker
I've never seen the dubbed version of Sailor Moon, only parts of the subbed; but I found this link that describes the countless changes made in the translation. (Warning--possible spoilers.)

http://www.geocities.com/Tokyo/5976/sm-miss.htm


I haven't looked at everything there, but I'm hoping that there isn't anything inappropriate. (To my memory, what little I did see was safe.) If there is anything inappropriate, someone please let me know and I'll edit this post accordingly by deleting the link.

PostPosted: Wed Jul 30, 2003 10:52 pm
by andyroo
It's been a few months since I've read those pages so I will see what I can remember.

[spoiler="I guess that you can call this spoiler material"]There is one about a kissing scene when some girl had her [life?] crystel(sp?) taken from her and some comments that followed. Not sure if there is a screencap for it or not. There is one episode that took an entire season (Super S) for the editors to draw over a females monster's chest. I'm pretty sure there is a screen cap of that. The unedited only had two stars. Probably TMI.[/spoiler]

It would be a good idea for you skim through those screen caps to make sure what I am saying is accurate.