I hate having two posts in a row, but I think I have a right to defend what I love.
Everyone talks about the Sony corporate BS... Being a somewhat isolated Sony fan, I think it's time I retaliated in a more systematic, thought out way... I'm gonna keep track of the anti-sony BS that people shovel.
Case 1: Kotaku's "Nintendo 64 is outselling PS3" report.
Reason why it is BS: The stats on Amazon depend on how well it sells... on Amazon. That scared me at first, I'm thinking "So, it's not selling well on Amazon?" Turns out, someone pointed out that Amazon
doesn't sell the PS3 themselves, but only handle resales. If you compare their native sales + resales ONLY to bloated resales when you can pick the system up for cheaper at any gamestop or target. Conversely, PS3 is on top at the UK site because people are
selling japanese and american systems. What makes this hillarious is that imports of a system like this are outselling those sold natively on the site, but there may be an explanation for THAT which I don't understand, part of which includes the updates, in which the order fluctuates wildly. Or, Sony did right in waiting 5 months to release in Europe and the US launch was an experiment. Hmm... Lets' see, 2 good games at launch + sports and racing games that the European audience is going to go crazy for, vs 1 good game at launch with a very small number of launch titles... Europe wins...
In the UK, the bloated 2000 dollar used american PS3 is beating everything except Final Fantasy XII at the moment of this posting...
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/bestsellers/videogames/ref=pd_ts_c_th_more/026-8586939-0732447
I could go and say that means Sony will wipe the floor with the competition in the UK. I could also say that it measns something that resistance is above the DS lite but I won't do that. Instead, I'll acknowledge that Amazon isn't the best source of info on how a system is doing, and that a lot of factors (the different versions of the DS lite, for instance, vs only one version of resistance) can influence these positions
Case 2: Sony loses nearly all of its exclusives.
Why it's BS: I won't argue that Sony lost exclusivity on a few of the top profile games. Virtua Fighter 5, Assassin's creed, and GTA4. There are still a LOT of exclusives... I didnt' realize this until looking at a PS3 fan forum, mostly because there is no other way, Sony's website included, to see this information consolidated. One of the bigger surprises is the once PC only (for good reason) FPS "The Wall" is now PC and PS3... I'm mixed about that, but the fact stands there are a lot of exclusives coming. Not as many as 360, but keep in mind it's been out longer for one, and hasn't had nearly as much bad press, warranted or not.
The list on PS3 forums, not counting some more iffy games (like the Team Ico project upcoming, which won't likely get here until 2009)
Afrika * (looks beautiful even if no one knows what it's really about)
Angel Rings
DMC 4 (looks a lot better now than it did last time I checked)
Eight Days
Eyedentify
Unnamed Eyetoy game.
Fifth Phantom Saga
F1 CE
FFXIII
FFXIII Vs
God of War III
Gran Tourissmo 5
Some crappy gundam game
Heavenly Sword
Heavy Rain (seriously, go check out the trailer on gametrailers.com... It looks like crap at first, but then it goes sorta "art house" and really got me interested)
Jak and Daxter
Killzone 2
Kingdom Hearts 3
Lair
Metal Gear Solid 4 (THE killer PS3 game of 07, and everyone knows it.)
Monster Hunter 3
Monster Kingdom
Motorstorm (Have you seen the updated game, not the crappy demo? That game is gorgeous, though it doesn't "surpass" the target renders like Sony BSed, it basically matches them now)
Ninja Gaiden Sigma
Ni-Oh
Rachet and Clank 5
Redwood Falls
Singstar PS3
Super Robot Taisen
Tekken 6
Eye of Judgement (Honestly... Magic the Gathering fanboys are going to be buying PS3s in droves after this is released... This concept is allready huge in arcades in Japan. Oh, and if they dont' know about it, I'll get it (as much as I hate card games) if only to show it off, heh) I figure this one deserves some explanation. It's a trading card game, like Magic, but the eyetoy is set up to see a board of 3x3 cards, and it reads the cards to produce monsters on the screen on the cards. You play just like real trading card games, literally tapping the cards to activate them. This thing is genius.
The getaway
The Wall (PC and PS3 only)
Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
Wardevil
Warhawk
Way of the Samurai
White Knight Story
Wipeout
Finally, the most anticipated game of all time, "Super Rub-a-dub" The game that uses the LoD engine... Lots of ducks. You finally get to play that duck demo that Phil Harrison showed off at E3 05. Hahahaah! I'll SO be getting that.
I want to fight the doom train, at least the car that prevails here at CAA, so even if I AM the only one posting, I'll do it... This list will be updated with more BS watch (I won't be pointing out Sony BS, because people see more of that than there is in the first place) as I see it.
EDIT: I know there are some exclusives missing from my list, even those that were on the PS3 forums... That's because I thought a crappy Gears ripoff, an RTS that looks like it was from PS1 era, and a couple others like that were too embarassing to include in the list.